Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Wednesday, 19th November 2008 Change Date

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Cameron claims Brown 'has gone bust'



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 29 September 2008
DAVID Cameron pledged to help people deal with the credit crunch as the Conservatives tried to wrest back the mantle of fiscal responsibility from Labour yesterday.
The Conservative leader branded the Prime Minister reckless with money as the party prepared to unveil its economic rescue plan. Opening the party conference in Birmingham, the Tory leader took a swipe at Gordon Brown and his bid to cast himself as t
he champion of economic competence.

"Who was it who said that he, and he alone, had rewritten the laws of economics to end boom and bust?" he told delegates. "The answer is our Prime Minister, the then chancellor, Gordon Brown. And my message to Gordon Brown is this: You have had your boom, and your reputation is now bust."

In a nod to the cautious economic climate, the Conservative leader cancelled the screening of a video which was meant to showcase the Tory Party's achievements over the last year. Mr Cameron is desperate to avoid accusations of hubris or taking voters for granted. In an interview, he said that the Tories may not have "sealed the deal" yet with the public.

Mr Cameron is also keen to reposition the party as a credible force to take charge of the economy.

A BPIX poll published yesterday gave Mr Brown and Alistair Darling, the Chancellor, a one per cent lead over Mr Cameron and George Osborne as the better-regarded team to deal with the current crisis in the markets.

"Let us show them that this is the end for the big spending, big taxing, recklessly borrowing, big, bossy, interfering government that promises so much and delivers so little," he said. "We have a plan for change, so let's show them that we can be that change."

Mr Cameron also insisted there should be no blank cheques to nationalise cash-strapped banks, as he signalled Conservative concerns over the bail-out of Bradford & Bingley.

The Tory Party would instead prefer more powers to be given to the Bank of England to take over ailing institutions before turning them round to sell on to private investors.

The Conservatives will step up the verbal assault today on the government's economic record, with Mr Osborne calling time on what he called "Gordon Brown's age of irresponsibility".

A plan to ride out the worst of the financial turbulence will also be published in a policy document today.

Measures include an office for budget responsibility, which would have the power to audit the nation's debts, including liabilities such as PFI projects, which are not currently counted on the government's books.

The Bank of England would also be given stronger powers to look out for debt, writing a regular letter to the Financial Services Authority on the extent of risk in the market.

Earlier, Mr Cameron said he and the shadow chancellor had been "vindicated" by not offering up-front tax cuts. To make such a promise would have been irresponsible, the Conservative leader said.

But there was embarrassment for the Tories yesterday when it emerged that the party had accepted almost £2 million from hedge-fund managers who took bets on banks such as HBOS, which was forced into an emergency rescue by Lloyds TSB.

Both Mr Cameron and Mr Osborne have declined to condemn short-selling.

REBEL OF THE DAY

Boris Johnson

The London mayor junked the party's financial straightjacket to offer Londoners a freeze in the council tax they pay to City Hall, and praised Labour MP Kate Hoey, who acts as his sports envoy.

GLUMMEST FACE

Theresa Villiers

The shadow transport secretary looked nervous when appearing on stage alongside fellow shadow cabinet members. She is frequently earmarked as being first for the chop in a Cameron reshuffle.

QUOTE OF THE DAY

He presumably thought trying to be Tarzan meant walking around with a banana

William Hague mocks David Miliband's so-called 'Heseltine moment' at last week's Labour Party conference

BIGGEST SMILE

Journalists in the media suite

They were handed endless freebies – topped by several varieties of Dairy Milk and a box of Heroes chocolates, courtesy of a small local business known as Cadbury.

BEST BIT OF GOSSIP

BORIS Johnson was an even bigger draw than his party leader on the opening day, with the hall packed well before the blond bombshell took to the stage.

And in characteristic style, his joking ruffled a few feathers.

Last week Labour attracted controversy by showing a film in which US presidential candidate Barack Obama praised Gordon Brown. For the Tories, they have been making great play of being even-handed with Democrat Mr Obama and his Republican rival John McCain.

Then along comes Boris to describe another prominent Republican, California governor Arnold Schwarzenegger, as a "monosyllabic Austrian cyborg".







The full article contains 795 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

 
1

Willie,

29/09/2008 00:12:54
Cameron's comment that the Bankers are not to blame for the current crisis is worrying.
Clearly money from Salmond's Spivs and Speculators for his party have clouded his judgement?
Maybe cricising others is easier that having principles, and sticking up for others than spivs, speculators and toffs.
Is he really prime minister material!!!!!
2

clochoderic,

lochfield 29/09/2008 01:18:31
Cameron is a diddy - Boris for the top job!
3

Marian,

29/09/2008 07:52:16
The chickens are now coming home to roost after 11 years of New Labour's "age of irresponsibility" (to quote G Brown himself). None of this needed to happen if the UK financial services industry had been properly controlled and managed as was done in other European countries who are escaping relatively unscathed by this disaster.
4

Citylocal Fife,

Fife News 29/09/2008 08:07:45
This is *not* news. Many of us have forecast this outcome for some time. It's simple arithmetic - something which Gordon Brown has never mastered.
5

LEAL,

29/09/2008 08:45:52
Britains going bust.We can no longer support the union
6

Mr. Lachie Todd,

Edinburgh 29/09/2008 09:40:37
All this week, The Independent (on Sunday), which broke the story about Cameron's two close associates involvement in a hedge fund will be running more details about the massive donations received from this company by the Tory Party.

During the recent economic crisis the managers of this hedge fund had been short-selling HBOS and other share stock and making massive profits.

This may account for Cameron's low profile during recent weeks?
7

Alan B,

29/09/2008 09:59:58
#Todd

Think Camerons low profile is more to do with the fact that sometimes politically is better to say nothing.

Slagging the opposition off all the time tends not to get any respect. Shutting up when your opposition are in mess and letting everyone else critise them is more politically expedient.

Problem is it does not give anyone any confidence in their competetence.

8

bluehead,

edinburgh 29/09/2008 10:03:27
politicians should undergo stringent tests to make sure they are fit for the job,as it is at the moment, great piles of this lot should be lucky to get a job selling boot laces ar a jumble sale,brown blames everything but himself for all the money problems,ignoring the fact that he was in charge of the treasury for years,it would not surprise me if he had to take his socks of to count past ten
9

connaughtboy,

stonehaven 29/09/2008 10:40:57
Why has no-one yet come up with a story on Labour connections to short-sellers? There's bound to be one!
10

Alternative (High-Octane) Fuel Head,

Edinburgh 29/09/2008 12:10:13
All very true.

Why were the Tories not saying this kind of thing 10 years ago when Brown started all this fiscal rot?
11

Cappo Del Monte,

29/09/2008 12:40:42
#10 and others
Please try and get some facts right here.
It was and has always been the tories fault.

If maggie hadnt demutualised the building societies in the first place, they wouldnt have had access to all the cheap monies avaliable to banks, its called the tories chickens coming home to roost. Encouraging small shareholders to buy buy buy also with house purchase, now regretting it. As it will be for all de-nationalise industries getting sold off to foreign governments.
You dont see any european govs selling their industries overseas, infact the very opposite, they do all they can to prevent / scupper it, even illegal moves
12

Alan B,

29/09/2008 12:52:05
#Cappo

Yes blame the tories for labour failings. The tories have not been in government for more than a decade.

The real underlying problem is the failure to control house price inflation and the failure to regulate the financial sector so that there is stability. (Remember it was labour that changed the regulatory framework).
13

Alan B,

29/09/2008 12:54:27
#10 Alternative

It is not clear the tories would have been any better. Would they have control house price inflation. Would they have control the growth of credit (early thatcher economic policy). Would they have regulated the financial sector better. We will never know.

What we do know is we have had a competely irresponsible labour government mismanaging the economy for a prolonged period of time.
14

Alan B,

29/09/2008 12:55:35
#Cappo

While the tories have their failings. Remember banks did not go bust under their watch. That has happened with a short termist power obsessed economically incompetentent labour government.
15

Arfur,

29/09/2008 12:56:23
#11 Cappo Del Monte - lets for one minute say that the tories got all of these banks into trouble - are you trying to say that ELEVEN years is not enough time to sort it out? This is due to the incompetence of Labour.
16

Voice of reason,

EDINBURGH 29/09/2008 13:32:35
It is Labour who invented the culture of greed, easy credit , get-rich-quick ,fame , celebrity - all on the back of talked up-house prices and not on the basis of actual earnings . They knew very well what a mess the country was really in but the stupid voters wre taken in by Blair etc . The old style bankers have been ousted by young , greedy , incompetent Blairite spivs .
17

danbob,

29/09/2008 13:36:03
14# Remember Barings in Febuary 1995. The failings were there in the tory years as well and to deny it is false. No government is ever going to regulate against the money earners whilst they are earning money that swell the tax coffers. It has all blown up in Browns face. But if he had called an election and lost two years ago it would have been Camerons face.
18

Alan B,

29/09/2008 13:58:44
#danbob

Barings was brought down by illegal trading. It was also a single individual bank. This is the entire banking sector that is in trouble.

Governments are resonsible for controlling house price inflation that is at the root of most of the problems.
19

Liz,

Edinburgh 29/09/2008 14:34:30
Hopefully soon Brown's reputation for prudence is put to rest (unless of course they are planning on redefining prudence).
Fact is, Mr Brown was desperate to claim credit for the so called 'good' years but he did nothing to protect people from their own stupidity - he was too busy riding high on the popularity polls as he helped fuel an illusion of wealth, formed mostly from an unchecked credit boom. I was reading something earlier that referred to 'sub-prime buy to let mortgages' - how such things did not set alarm bells ringing in the Treasury I do not know. As a result of all this lax and idiotic lending, many banks are heading to the wall. Our 'Greatest Ever Chancellor' should have seen this coming (even I did) and done something about it.
20

Cappo Del Monte,

29/09/2008 15:15:08
#12
Yes I can blame the tories for demutalising building societies ( please read my statement properly, In no part have I mentioned credit crunch or banks )did you actually READ what was in my comment?
The tax payers money is being used to bail out demutualised building societies not banks, and maggie relaxed those rules and banking regulatory ones long before the bufoon liebour party, try looking into history.
By that statement, you can just see the torries for the next decade blaming it all on labour ( maggie started it and liebour just kept on pushing the same policies )

#14
What bank has gone bust, some have been taken over, de-mutualised building societies have gone bust! Fact ( And again if maggie hadnt relaxed the rules they would never have got in this situation, oh and that is another Fact )

21

Cappo Del Monte,

29/09/2008 15:17:51
#15

Can you please tell me where I said Banks, where?



22

Cappo Del Monte,

29/09/2008 15:18:56
A little fact maggie started it maggie broon just kept on with the same policies pretending they were his
23

Alan B,

29/09/2008 16:38:58
#Cappo

The demutualised building societies became banks. As such it was banks under banking regulations that went bust.
24

Alan B,

29/09/2008 16:47:17
#Cappo

There are arguments for and against demutualisation. But demutualisation is not what caused these instututions to go bust.

It was
-the drying up of the global credit markets
-the over relience on the credit markets to fund mortgage lending rather than deposits. check the different ratios between lloyds and hbos.
-the uncontrolled house price inflation which underpinned the credit boom and personal debt.

If the government had controlled house price inflation. This would not have happened. Credit controls on lending both from the pespective of the lender who should only be able to borrow within certain limits of salary with deposits etc. Also lack of house price inflation would not have fed the frenzy to buy property.

If the government had regulated banks to ensure more stability ie higher deposit to debt ratios.

Demutualised companies by their nature would not have got into trouble. But conversely it was not demutualisation that caused the problems.
25

Matt there,

Somewhere 29/09/2008 16:56:59
Yes, Cappo! And that Lord Palmerston! Oh! How ge damamged the economy even to the present day!

And I am sure that Lord Walshingham's handiwork can be seen in the current mess, too!
26

Rodster,

Glasgow 30/09/2008 06:10:07
To the Tories or Labour I say " a plague on both your houses"
However at least with the Real Tories you always know what you are going to get.
Labour are finished for decades to come, or until such times as they rediscover their roots .
The Tories will as always have to come in at their back and clear up the mess.
And so it goes on , and on .
We have a chance to rid ourselves of this Westminster pantomime once and for all .
ITS TIME!
27

Bird of Prey, Will Pan what you say,

28/10/2008 03:54:51
Im back

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Today's Vote

Has David Cameron done enough to prove he can be Prime Minister?
Yes
No

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.